Ballot Access Lawsuit

Direct link to this page:
Share Button


This lawsuit was filed due to our request to view ballots was denied by the Registrar of Voters, Michael Vu. The goal of this request and the first few rounds of request are found here:

We suspect possible tampering of the Early VBM ballots in the 2016 Primary election -- the only ballots where Clinton won over Sanders. All other ballot categories (polling places, Later VBM and Provisional) Sanders was the winner. Election officials must preserve the ballots for 22 months after the election. But they claim also that they are "sealed" and no one can see them. However, there is no dispute that these are public records and there is no specific exemption for voted ballots, and there is no voter-identifiable information on them. We believe the seal is only to preserve the ballots, not keep them from public review.

As of Friday, October 6:
The county responded to our complaint with a demurrer, which challenges the legal basis of our complaint. We filed an opposition to the demurrer and now we will have a hearing on Oct 13 2017, in this preliminary phase. If we win, then the case proceeds, and the county will have to respond to our complaint in full.

As of Friday, October 13
Hearing on the demurrer resulted in the court SUSTAINING it, with prejudice. That means the next step is to appeal it.


  • 2017-07-25 -- Lawsuit officially filed.
  • 2017-07-31 -- Notice of similar case -- referenced Election Audit Lawsuit.
  • 2017-09-11 -- County files demurrer
  • 2017-09-26 -- Opposition to demurrer filed by Plaintiff
  • 2017-10-12 -- Tentative Ruling (Sustaining Demurrer)
  • 2017-10-13 -- Court hearing scheduled for 10:30am, Dept 66 (Hon. Kenneth J. Medel) - No changes to tentative ruling. Judge indicates he expects this to be appealed.


Object tag not supported. Click here to view the document.
If the document does not display above, click here


This case was appealed to allow the appellate court to decide if the CPRA law should allow citizens to access ballots.

Special Request for Amicus Briefs

The time window for this opportunity has passed. This included only for historical reference.

If you are associated with an Election Integrity Organization, or generally have an interest in open government, we hereby request that you file an AMICUS BRIEF to support the access of paper ballots by the public based on the CPRA law and related constitutional amendment that says that existing laws should be interpreted narrowly, in favor of access. Other states (such as Florida, Ohio and New York) allow access of paper voted ballots by way of a public records request. Please see the documents above, particularly the Demurrer Points and Authorities and the Opposition to Demurrer to gain an understanding of the positions. Essentially, the County says they can't allow access because they are sealed. Our position is that "sealed" does not mean no one can look at them, it only means the County will not continue to manipulate them. We believe that given that other states DO allow access by public records law, that there is no sound rationale to keep them sealed, and thus access should be given based on the intent of the CPRA law and the related constitutional amendment.

If this approach does not work, then we will need to pursue a legislative approach to change the law to allow review of voted ballots. The Amicus Briefs should be prepared by an attorney with familiarity in the art. Please contact if you can make this happen!

Direct link to this page:

Summary of articles submitted (Add | All):

Number of topics: 15

Discussion List

See List Serve for all email discussion lists and to add more.

Project Form edit

Project Name Ballot Access Lawsuit
Project Description Lawsuit against the San Diego Registrar of Voters to Access Ballots as Public Records
Project Founder Ray Lutz
Project Curator Ray Lutz
Project Type Issue Oversight
Project Parents Election Integrity
Related Keywords Easy Voting, Election Team, Snapshot Protocol, Election Audit Lawsuit, Snapshot Protocol
Project Status Active
Publish Status Published
Thumbnail Link
Forum Link
List Serve Topic Election Integrity List
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date Who Comment
Appeal of <a class="foswikiCurrentTopicLink" href="/Common/BallotAccessLawsuit">Ballot Access Lawsuit</a>-AppelateCase-D073522.pdfpdf Appeal of BallotAccessLawsuit-AppelateCase-D073522.pdf manage 1 MB 2018-06-29 - 22:35 Raymond Lutz Appeal of Ballot Access Lawsuit, Appellate Case: D073522
Appellants Opening Brief FINAL.pdfpdf Appellants Opening Brief FINAL.pdf manage 356 K 2019-03-10 - 23:25 Raymond Lutz Appellants Opening Brief
Appellants Reply Brief.pdfpdf Appellants Reply Brief.pdf manage 2 MB 2019-03-10 - 23:26 Raymond Lutz Appellants Reply Brief
BallotAccessLawsuitImage.JPGJPG BallotAccessLawsuitImage.JPG manage 86 K 2017-10-07 - 02:54 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-07-25_-_Complaint_CPRA_FINAL_w_Exhibits.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-07-25_-_Complaint_CPRA_FINAL_w_Exhibits.pdf manage 2 MB 2017-10-07 - 02:10 Raymond Lutz Ballot Access - 2017-07-25 - Complaint CPRA FINAL w Exhibits
Ballot_Access_-_2017-07-31_-_Notice_of_Related_Case.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-07-31_-_Notice_of_Related_Case.pdf manage 636 K 2017-10-07 - 02:16 Raymond Lutz Notice of related case
Ballot_Access_-_2017-08-04_-_Objections_to_Notice_of_Related_Cases.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-08-04_-_Objections_to_Notice_of_Related_Cases.pdf manage 191 K 2017-10-07 - 02:16 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Dec_of_Tim_Barry_re_Demurrer_09122017.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Dec_of_Tim_Barry_re_Demurrer_09122017.pdf manage 238 K 2017-10-07 - 02:21 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Notice_09122017.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Notice_09122017.pdf manage 160 K 2017-10-07 - 02:18 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Ps_As_Demurrer_09122017.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-11_-_Demurrer_Ps_As_Demurrer_09122017.pdf manage 495 K 2017-10-07 - 02:19 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-26_-_Opposition_to_Dumurrer.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-09-26_-_Opposition_to_Dumurrer.pdf manage 40 K 2017-10-07 - 02:23 Raymond Lutz  
Ballot_Access_-_2017-10-12_Tentative_Ruling.pdfpdf Ballot_Access_-_2017-10-12_Tentative_Ruling.pdf manage 14 K 2017-10-13 - 05:00 Raymond Lutz Tentative Ruling
D073522-Citizens Oversight vs. Vu CT Vol 1of1.pdfpdf D073522-Citizens Oversight vs. Vu CT Vol 1of1.pdf manage 4 MB 2019-03-10 - 23:28 Raymond Lutz Clerk's transcript of Ballot Access Lawsuit case
Motion for Judicial Notice.pdfpdf Motion for Judicial Notice.pdf manage 2 MB 2019-03-10 - 23:29 Raymond Lutz Judicial Notice in Ballot Access Lawsuit appeal
Topic revision: r10 - 2019-03-10, RaymondLutz
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Cops? Send feedback