Direct link to this page: http://copswiki.org/Common/EnergyPolicy
As oil prices reach record highs, we hear renewed interest in doing something, such as drilling in ANWR (Arctic National Wildlife Refuge) or reopening coastal drilling. What should we do?
Is Drilling the Answer?
It seems Big Oil can't get enough! Did you know that oil companies are already sitting on 68 million acres of leases that they aren't even drilling? Which kind of makes you wonder: Why are Big Oil and its allies suddenly desperate to get their hands on the last few places that are still protected -- our natural treasures, wildlife refuges, and pristine coastlines? They wouldn't use the concerns caused by high gas prices as an excuse to grab it ALL, would they? Thank you Speaker Pelosi for keeping a cool head and holding out for real solutions!
Is ANWR the answer?
- Analysis of Crude Oil Production in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (May 2008) - http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/servicerpt/anwr/pdf/sroiaf(2008)03.pdf
- projected to increase domestic crude oil production starting in 2018, estimated at reaches 780,000 barrels per day in 2027 and then declines to 710,000 barrels per day in 2030.
- Between 2018 and 2030, cumulative additional oil production is 2.6 billion barrels
- Decreases import dependency by 2% at the peak.
- Improves balance of trade $202 billion dollars (2006 dollars) in the mean oil resource case
- The opening of ANWR is projected to have its largest oil price reduction impacts as follows:
- a reduction in low-sulfur, light crude oil prices of $0.41 per barrel (2006 dollars) in 2026 for the low oil resource case,
- $0.75 per barrel in 2025 for the mean oil resource case, and
- $1.44 per barrel in 2027
- In 1998, the USGS estimated that between 5.7 and 16.0 billion barrels of technically recoverable oil are in the coastal plain area of ANWR.
- In comparison, the estimated volume of undiscovered, technically recoverable oil in the rest of the United States is about 120 billion barrels.
- Thus, ANWR represents about 10% of the oil reserves in the US.
projected ANWR oil production constitutes between 0.4 and 1.2 percent of total world oil consumption in 2030
Consequently, ANWR oil production is not projected to have a large impact on world oil prices, about $0.75 per barrel in 2025 in the mean oil resource case
The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) could neutralize any potential price impact of ANWR oil production by reducing its oil exports.
The fact is that we can almost immediately improve our situation by far more than 10% by taking low-efficiency vehicles off the road. Going from 20 mpg to 30 mpg is a 50% improvement. Even taking the average from 20 mpg to 22 mpg makes up for all the oil from ANWR, if indeed it would provide 10% of the supply, and it does it with the same balance of trade improvements
(of course, it would be nice if the US automakers had some decent hybrids, which they actively killed, along with the EV-1 electric car to allow them to introduce the Hummer). By not buying the oil at all (or using up our precious and limited natural resources) we preserve the wealth of our economy and our nation. We can do far more, faster, by conserving, esp. since it will be 2018 before any ANWR oil comes on line. By conserving, more oil will remain on the market and then prices "should" fall. Of course, it also has the added benefit that we would be producing fewer emissions, and even for climate-change nay-sayers like yourself, I'm sure you can appreciate the idea that less pollution is better.
- the average fuel economy of the cars and trucks on the road is at a twenty-one year low!
The demands for developing ANWR are ridiculous, esp. when we haven't done anything to improve fleet efficiency. It's like a homeowner complaining about heating costs but not installing any insulation, and then leaving the windows open, while demanding that the temp is a sweltering 81 in the house.
- Automakers have the technology today to produce a fleet of cars and light trucks that averages 40 mpg. The modest increase in sticker prices will be more than offset by the fuel savings. On average, drivers will save more than $2,200 over the lifetime of the vehicle.
- Comparison of fuel economy standards:
"Automobile fuel economy standards have proven to be one of the most effective tools in controlling oil
demand and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the transportation sector in many regions and countries around
the world. While fuel economy standards for light-duty vehicles have been largely stagnant in the United States over
the past two decades, the rest of the world-especially the European Union, Japan, and recently China and
California-has moved forward, establishing or tightening GHG or fuel economy standards."
- CAFE standards vs actual economy in US:
This is the crux of the problem. See that drooping blue line? That is the poor efficiency of our cars and trucks that has been the result of the popular mega-mammoth SUV sold in the US for the past 20 years. The two red lines represent CAFE standards for cars and light trucks respectively. The two black lines represent fleet-average fuel economy
achieved separately by cars and light trucks. Drilling for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and other special places would not curb our dependence on foreign oil.
Raising fuel economy standards is the most effective way to reduce overall oil dependence.
- The U.S. holds only 3 percent of the world's oil reserves and uses 25 percent of the world's produced oil.
- Persian Gulf countries hold over 65 percent of the world's oil reserves.
- The total projected yield from the Arctic Refuge would increase world oil reserves by less than one-third of 1 percent.
- Opening the Arctic Refuge today would not produce oil until at least 2010 and, based on the current rate of consumption, would yield only a sixmonth supply of oil over 50 years. Phasing in a fleet wide fuel economy standard of 40 mpg by 2012 would save more oil in the next dozen years than the total projected yield from the Arctic Refuge.
- The Arctic Refuge would only reduce U.S. imports from 64 percent to 62 percent in 2020.
- Domestic oil production is expensive. While it costs deepwater drillers like Exxon Mobil or Conoco roughly $6 to $8 to produce a barrel in the Gulf of Mexico or the North Sea, producing oil in Saudi Arabia or Kuwait costs a fraction of that-$1 a barrel or less.
- Increasing domestic oil production would not protect the U.S. from price spikes because there are no regional markets for oil, only global. If world oil prices spike, so do domestic oil prices.
- Domestic oil infrastructure is itself vulnerable to terrorism, as illustrated by the effects of a single bullet shot into the trans-Alaska pipeline, which caused a spill of 6,800 barrels or 285,600 gallons of oil. A more concerted effort could easily disrupt domestic supplies and have serious economic impacts.
- Cars and light trucks account for 40 percent of U.S oil use-8 mbd.
- Raising fuel economy standards for new cars, SUVs and other light trucks to an average of 40 mpg over the next 10 years will save nearly 2 mbd in 2012 and nearly 4 mbd by the end of the next decade. This is more oil than current imports from the Persian Gulf and the projected yield from the Arctic Refuge, combined.
- Raising fuel economy standards for cars and light trucks to 40 mpg over the next decade would yield cumulative oil savings of 3 billion barrels by 2012 and more than 12 billion barrels by 2020.
Airline executives recently published a letter (attached) which makes the assertion that speculation
is the root cause of our high prices today. They say:
Twenty years ago, 21 percent of oil contracts were purchased by speculators who trade oil on paper with no intention of
ever taking delivery. Today, oil speculators purchase 66 percent of all oil futures contracts, and that reflects just the
transactions that are known. Speculators buy up large amounts of oil and then sell it to each other again and again. A
barrel of oil may trade 20-plus times before it is delivered and used; the price goes up with each trade and consumers pick
up the final tab. Some market experts estimate that current prices reflect as much as $30 to $60 per barrel in unnecessary
Over seventy years ago, Congress established regulations to control excessive, largely unchecked market speculation
and manipulation. However, over the past two decades, these regulatory limits have been weakened or removed. We
believe that restoring and enforcing these limits, along with several other modest measures, will provide more disclosure,
transparency and sound market oversight. Together, these reforms will help cool the over-heated oil market and permit
the economy to prosper.
Fixing this broken market is the fastest, cheapest way to deal with the problem, with immediate returns to the economy.
ANWR is an important wildlife refuge that should be preserved, esp. since we are currently at a 21-year low in terms of fleet efficiency. Conservation must be our first order of business. Developing ANWR without having completed a massive improvement in our conservation would be quite unethical, as the technology is available to improve our efficiency far more than 10%, and that is the same as the contribution by ANWR. The same argument is true for the coastal drilling proposals. Unfortunately, President Bush's plan completely neglected conservation as an element in our Energy Policy.
Recent Articles and Media: (Add | All Media)
- (M1731) A PRUDENT VIEW OF EARTHQUAKE RISKS, NUCLEAR PLANTS AND NUCLEAR WASTE ALONG THE CALIFORNIA COAST -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2017-03-01
- (M1660) Lies, damned lies and the nuclear industry strikes out again. -- Ace Hoffman, Citizens Oversight, 2016-06-23
- (M1651) State agrees to review Powerlink EMFs -- Supervisor Jacob worries about SDG&E involvement in the investigation -- Jeff Mc Donald, Union Tribune, 2016-03-04
- (M1650) 2016-02-23 Sunrise Powerlink EMI in Alpine Meeting -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2016-02-23
- (M1649) 2016 02 14 Porter Ranch Tour -- Richard Mathews -- Ray Lutz, Richard Mathews, Citizens Oversight, 2016-02-14 Porter Ranch So Cal Gas Richard Mathews
- (M1572) Energy Policy Legislation (California) -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2015-04-14
- (M1552) Citizens Oversight's Federal Case Against Edison, CPUC Ignited by Warsaw Meetings & Felony Searches -- Aguirre Severson LLP, Citizens Oversight, 2015-02-25 2/25/2015 Filings -- Southern California Edison
- (M1546) Peevey Network -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2015-02-22
- (M1542) Shut up! Shut up! -- Edison admits secret huddle with Michael Peevey on San Onofre -- Don Bauder, San Diego Reader, 2015-02-09 Related to: Peevey Party Protest
- (M1541) INDUSTRY TO TOAST EX-PUC CHIEF PEEVEY -- Celebration for former utilities chief comes amid state corruption investigation -- Jeff Mc Donald, Union Tribune, 2015-02-02 Related to: Peevey Party Protest
- (M1534) Report of Malfeasance and Institutional Corruption at the California Public Utilities Commission -- Mike Aguirre and Mia Severson, Aguirre Severson LLP, 2015-01-07 Ray Lutz contributed to this paper.
- (M1527) Guidelines for the post-Peevey era of the CPUC -- Loretta M. Lynch, San Francisco Chronicle, 2014-12-19
- (M1525) NRC Division of Spent Fuel Management (DSFM) Regulatory Conference -- , Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2014-11-19
- (M1512) CPRA Response in San Bruno Explosion Case -- CPUC and PG&E -- , Citizens Oversight, 2014-10-24 Thousands of emails provided in CPRA response from CPUC illustrates a culture of corruption -- San Bruno Explosion Peevey Party Protest
- (M1476) Thorium -- Helen Caldicott, Huffington Post, 2014-07-01
- (M1440) Settling The Bill For Closing The San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station -- Erik Anderson, Kpbs Radio, 2014-05-14
- (M1435) Who pays for a worthless power plant? -- Morgan Lee, Union Tribune, 2014-05-11 This story explains how billions of ratepayer dollars are at stake as opposed to the phony claims of $1.4 Billion in refunds.
- (M1434) Nuclear deal slams consumers, as usual -- Dan Mc Swain, Union Tribune, 2014-05-10 Features Senator Barbara Boxer
- (M1427) Settlement Press Conference on 2014-05-06 -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2014-05-01
- (M1428) Ruling by ALJs on Settlement Schedule -- , California Public Utilities Commission, 2014-04-25
- (M1423) $3.3B Fair or Foul? -- Morgan Lee, Union Tribune, 2014-04-20 Mentions Michael Aguirre
- (M1425) REPORT ON HEALTH STATUS OF RESIDENTS IN SAN LUIS OBISPO AND SANTA BARBARA COUNTIES LIVING NEAR THE DIABLO CANYON NUCLEAR REACTORS -- Joseph Mangano, World Business Academy, 2014-03-03
- (M1520) Into Eternity - Tour of Onkalo Nuclear Waste Repository in Finland -- , Magic Hour Films, 2014-02-03 Excellent and detailed tour of the Onkalo Nuclear waste repository in Finland and related concerns.
- (M1400) Solar's Growth Upends State's Power System -- Matthew L. Wald, Orange County Register, 2013-12-30
- (M1406) NRC notice of violation on SONGS steam generator design -- , Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2013-12-23
- (M1396) CDSO Opening Brief on the Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding, A.12-12-012/013 -- Ray Lutz, Martha Sullivan, Citizens Oversight, 2013-12-16
- (M1426) Economic Considerations Guiding Shutdown of San Onofre -- , Southern California Edison, 2013-11-13
- (M1436) Closing of nuke helps Edison to higher earnings -- Eric Wolff, SNL Generation Markets Week, 2013-11-05
- (M1402) CPUC Nuclear Decommissioning Cost Triennial Proceeding 2012 -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Overisight, 2013-10-21 CPUC:A.12-12-012/013
- (M1401) CPUC Evidentiary Hearing on San Onofre (Phase 2) -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2013-10-07
- (M1405) SONGS - NRC Confirmatory Action Letter Response -- , Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2013-09-20
- (M1366) Storage of nuclear waste from spent fuel at San Onofre -- Robert Alvarez, Friends Of The Earth, 2013-06-25 An excellent overview of the current situation at San Onofre and concerns about the safety of nuclear waste.
- (M1568) RSG Notes on Hotel Bristol Stationery -- Michael Peevey, Stephen Pickett, Citizens Oversight, 2013-03-26 Received on 2015-04-10
- (M1347) CPUC Public Participation Hearing on San Onofre (Costa Mesa) -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2013-02-21 Transcripts Included.
- (M1288) GE Chief: Nuclear 'hard to justify' -- Pilita Clark, CNN, 2012-07-30
- (M1287) Japan Workers 'Told to Lie About Radiation' -- , Common Dreams, 2012-07-29
- (M1286) Concerns of Fukushima parallel in Calif. -- Erin Burnett Out Front, CNN, 2012-07-27
- (M1284) Nuclear Power Struggle: San Onofre's big promises and big failure -- Rob Davis, San Diego Magazine, 2012-07-23
- (M1282) Calif. energy officials plan for longer San Onofre nuclear plant shutdown -- Ed Joyce, Scpr.org, 2012-07-22
- (M1280) Activists call NRC Ruling 'Dangerous Coverup' -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-07-20
- (M1285) San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station -- NRC Augmented Inspection Team Report -- , Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 2012-07-18 S:DRS\REPORTS\SONGS 2012007 AIT-GEW, ADAMS Accession No.: ML12188 A748
- (M1308) 'Shut Down San Onofre': The New Front Line in the Fight Against Nuclear Power -- Jon Wiener, The Nation, 2012-07-05
- (M1270) Friends of the Earth Press Conference regarding Petition on San Onofre -- Friends of the Earth, Citizens Oversight, 2012-06-18
- (M1271) Petition to Intervene and Request for Hearing by Friends of the Earth -- Friends Of The Earth, Friends Of The Earth, 2012-06-18
- (M1309) Previously Classified Documents Unveil Potential Fire Dangers At San Onofre -- Randy Paige, Cbs News, 2012-05-14 Features Daniel Hirsch
- (M1258) Rally to Shut San Onofre / A short film by Ace Hoffman -- Ace Hoffman, Citizens Oversight, 2012-04-29 Condensation of events at the April 29 Rally; A29 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1253) Citizens Submit Requests on San Onofre to NRC Chairman Jaczko; Momentum Building for "Shut Down San Onofre" Rally April 29th; Earthquake and Plant Fire add to Safety Concerns following Radioactivity Release -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-04-25
- (M1254) Letter to NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko Requesting Specific Steps before restarting the San Onofre reactors -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-04-25
- (M1250) Steam Generator Failures at San Onofre -- Arnie Gundersen, Fairewinds Associates, 2012-03-27
- (M1247) Fukushima Remembered Rally at San Onofre -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-03-11 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1246) Fukushima Remembered: March 11 Anniversary Rally / Protest at San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station (SONGS) -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-03-09 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1245) 'Midnight in Paris' Actress Mimi Kennedy to Join Other Distinguished Speakers at Remember Fukushima Rally in San Onofre, March 11 -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-03-06 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1244) Robert F. Kennedy Jr. In San Diego -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-03-03
- (M1243) Two Speakers from Fukushima Area to Address 3/11 Rally at San Onofre -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-03-01 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1242) Scientists: Nuclear power isnít viable without corporate welfare -- David Worthington, Smart Planet, 2012-02-23 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1240) Press Release: Fukushima Remembered - San Onofre Protest and Rally -- Ray Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2012-02-20 M11 San Onofre Protest And Rally
- (M1255) Powering up: Nuclear plant to boost output -- Pat Brennan, Orange County Register, 2012-01-05
- (M1184) Suggested Goals of the Occupy Movement -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2011-10-28
- (M1176) Sunrise Powerlink: No help in Blackout -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2011-09-19
- (M1177) The Machinery of Climate Anti-Science -- John R Mashey, , 2011-04-04
- (M1121) Financing, legal woes block big Imperial Valley solar project -- Onell Soto, Union Tribune, 2010-12-13
- (M997) Lutz Slams Filibuster of $30 Billion Small Business Bill -- Ray Lutz, Lutz For Congress 2010, 2010-07-29
- (M1063) Powerlink booster may have powered up too soon Official was lobbying within 10 months of leaving the state -- Jeff Mc Donald, Union Tribune, 2010-07-15
- (M993) 'Full Containment' plan to stop the Deepwater Horizon leak -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2010-06-24
- (M994) 'Full Containment' Plan News Release -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2010-06-23
- (M992) Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill 'Full Containment' Plan - Whitepaper submitted to DHS -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2010-06-18 Deepwater Horizon
- (M985) Sunrise Powerlink Meeting in Alpine, 2010-05-10 -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2010-05-10 SDG&E attempted to thwart recording of the meeting, Ray Lutz said he would continue to record unless he was arrested.
- (M1064) Way too cozy! Private meetings between SDG&E officials, and state public utility commissioners. -- Michael Turko, Kusi News, 2010-04-20 SDG&E wines and dines CPUC officials just before the Sunrise Powerlink approval
- (M973) Power outage questions probed -- Shut-off of Otay Mesa plant remains unclear -- Onell Soto, Union Tribune, 2010-04-03 Power outage caused COPs office computer to go offline, an example of potential cyber terrorism.
- (M832) Taking a Dim View of Solar Energy -- Matthew Philips, News Week, 2009-08-25
- (M765) Sunrise Powerlink Community Meeting, Alpine, April 6, 2009 -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2009-04-06
- (M757) Comments on SDG&E Fire Safety by Donna Tisdale -- Donna Tisdale, Citizens Oversight, 2009-03-17
- (M743) Lakeside Community Speaks out against Sunrise Powerlink In El Monte Valley -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2009-02-25
- (M1251) Nuclear station to get new towers of power -- MIcheal Burge, Union Tribune, 2009-02-04 Shows how new steam Generators were transported to the plant
- (M660) A Question of power -- Stop the Sunrise Powerlink -- Diane Conklin Donna Tisdale, Citizens Oversight, 2008-10-20 Very important description of the ridiculous Sunrise Powerlink
- (M658) Foreign Liquefied Natural Gas -- Amita Sharma Amy Isackson, Kpbs News, 2008-10-13
- (M1586) Nuclear energy: assessing the emissions -- Kurt Kleiner, Nature.com, 2008-09-24
- (M622) Comment on Recirculated draft environmental impact report/supplemental draft environmental impact statement for the Sunrise powerlink transmission project -- Steven Siegel, Justin Augustine, Center For Biological Diversity & Sierra Club, 2008-08-25
- (M621) Contribution to the Recirculated Draft EIR for the Sunrise Powerlink (regarding the RWEP) (Lutz) -- Raymond Lutz, Citizens Oversight, 2008-08-04 [Proves that claims of 1250 MW is not feasible in 7500 acre area proposed.]
- (M566) San Diego City Attorney's INTERIM REPORT NO. 32: CALIFORNIA’S RENEWABLE ENERGY MANDATE IN PERIL -- Michael Aguirre, San Diego City Attorney, 2008-07-08
- (M1424) AB 1632 ASSESSMENT OF CALIFORNIAíS OPERATING NUCLEAR PLANTS -- , California Energy Commission, 2008 Shutdown Diablo
- (M719) The American Denial of Global Warming -- Naomi Oreskes, Ph.D., Ucsd Tv, 2007-12-20 Important encapsulation of Global Warming issue and the plan to undermine it.
- (M657) Biofuels: The Science of Creating Greener Energy -- , Ucsd Tv Molecules For The Media, 2007-09-24
- (M677) Cadem Resolution: Support Clean Energy -- Dante Atkins, delegate, 42nd Assembly District, Andrew Lachman; Democrats for Israel Los Angeles, Cadem Resolutions Committee, 2007-07-15
- (M678) Cadem Resolution: Opposing Coal Liquefaction -- Dante Atkins, DSCC Member, AD-42, and Platform Committee Member, Cadem Resolutions Committee, 2007-07-15
- (M680) Cadem Resolution: Local Planning to End Global Warming -- Luke Breit, Chair, CDP Environmental Caucus, Cadem Resolutions Committee, 2007-07-15
- (GreatGlobalWarmingSwindle) Great Global Warming Swindle -- Martin Durkin, Martin Durkin,
- (M1239) Dr. John Gofman comments on nuclear energy -- , Citizens Oversight,
- (M1353) Public Utilities Code Section 455.5 -- , State Of California,