COPS Comments on VVSG 2.0

CitizensOversight (2023-06-07) RayLutz

This Page: copswiki.org/Common/M1998

Remote Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/156cND9-8dvaiHwdiUPunpZA9h_JxhbVf7EHHkeoPets
More Info: ElectionEquipment

COPS VVSG 2.0 Comments

• This is our primary comments document to the Election Assistance Commission (AEC) as comment to the Voluntary Voting Systems Guidelines (VVSG)
• Please send your name to raylutz@citizensoversight.org if you want to endorse!
• Here is the current (and working) document which may be updated from the formal submission.
• https://docs.google.com/document/d/156cND9-8dvaiHwdiUPunpZA9h_JxhbVf7EHHkeoPets
• The version submitted to the VVSG
• COPS VVSG 2.0 Comments (M1998).pdf.pdf): COPS VVSG Comments

Improving Election Systems Cybersecurity

• This document details the steps in the protocol to fully secure the ballot images from when they are scanned and can be tracked all the way through the system
• Working Version
• https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vZYATrxiA6vJ-2azdLG2jqOqXTDn7s68RotEFJeeByo
• The version submitted to the VVSG
• Improving Election Systems Cybersecurity (M1999).pdf.pdf): Improving Election Cybersecurity (official Submission as VVSG 2.0 comments on 2023-06-07

Hand Marked Ballot Standard

• We need a better standard for the paper ballot so all machines will use the same format which is much better cryptographically, and can limit some copying scams.
• https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H898yQcvzBAhZwqPtZpXSkFmxz3kkAkjBdKOYKcnnjg

Guidelines and Terminology on the Ease of Vote Verification

• This paper defines different levels of vote verification by voters and auditors. The conclusion is that the best voting method is the hand-marked paper ballot, and worst are BMDs with unverifiable QR Codes or Barcodes.
• https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Qz9Iin4AwzwNxVPHPoZZmV9W0EfQp5JcdSN6JqEAErM/edit?usp=sharing